Torurot,
Kharzi is a Pashtun, as are many people in government. So how can we be at war with the whole tribe? I think your misunderstanding Afghan tribes. Who is your brother tribesman today may very well be your enemy tomorrow. Yes when an Invader comes through (be it Alexander, the British or the UN) they all come together but to pretend they all get along is not correct. What about all those sucide bombers in market places in Pashtun towns, they care about each other so much they strap explosives to themselves and blown up as many civilians as possible.
As for your question what has Afghanistan done to me. Personally nothing. But as I was trying to explain yesterday, we are at war with the Taliban who are not one and the same as Afghanistan.
We are at war with the Taliban as they continue to hide Al Queda, the guys who love to bring down buildings, and even today behead a Brit returning from a concert premoting diversity and tolerance. (such nice guys)
For Iraq, I'm not going to try and justify that war as I don't believe it needed to be fought. Having said that Saddam had already invaded his neighbours twice and I have trouble believing he wouldn't do it again should the sanctions have been lifted, with unkown consequences.
As for you solution to withdraw. Who knows, it may work but I have trouble beliving it as Afghans have been fighting each other since day zero. Once were gone they'll probably go back to it. Also in my own life I've never know a problem to disappear by sitting round and doing nothing.
In Iraq it would just lead to another power vacume which would no doubt be filled by someone (most probably Iran, who the Arab Sunni's are scared shitless off) And again back to square one.
I hope I've answered your questions, and I should tell you I'm not an American.
Kharzi is a Pashtun, as are many people in government. So how can we be at war with the whole tribe? I think your misunderstanding Afghan tribes. Who is your brother tribesman today may very well be your enemy tomorrow. Yes when an Invader comes through (be it Alexander, the British or the UN) they all come together but to pretend they all get along is not correct. What about all those sucide bombers in market places in Pashtun towns, they care about each other so much they strap explosives to themselves and blown up as many civilians as possible.
As for your question what has Afghanistan done to me. Personally nothing. But as I was trying to explain yesterday, we are at war with the Taliban who are not one and the same as Afghanistan.
We are at war with the Taliban as they continue to hide Al Queda, the guys who love to bring down buildings, and even today behead a Brit returning from a concert premoting diversity and tolerance. (such nice guys)
For Iraq, I'm not going to try and justify that war as I don't believe it needed to be fought. Having said that Saddam had already invaded his neighbours twice and I have trouble believing he wouldn't do it again should the sanctions have been lifted, with unkown consequences.
As for you solution to withdraw. Who knows, it may work but I have trouble beliving it as Afghans have been fighting each other since day zero. Once were gone they'll probably go back to it. Also in my own life I've never know a problem to disappear by sitting round and doing nothing.
In Iraq it would just lead to another power vacume which would no doubt be filled by someone (most probably Iran, who the Arab Sunni's are scared shitless off) And again back to square one.
I hope I've answered your questions, and I should tell you I'm not an American.
Comment